Metrics turn distance into neighborhoods
Objective: Why can the theorem in “Metrics turn distance into neighborhoods” not be reused blindly in this boundary case: A nonnegative symmetric function without the triangle inequality need not support the ball-intersection proof. Name the first failed hypothesis or implication.
A metric d on X is nonnegative, symmetric, separates points, and satisfies d(x,z)≤d(x,y)+d(y,z); B_r(x)={y:d(x,y)<r}. This tells us which objects and open-set choices the chapter is about.
The result to establish is: The union of open balls defines a topology because arbitrary unions and finite intersections of ball-open sets remain open. The proof begins with “The empty set and X satisfy the ball-open condition immediately.” and closes with “For a finite intersection, take the smallest of the finitely many available radii.” Keep the carrier set, topology, arbitrary point or cover, and implication direction visible throughout.
The worked question is: Compare Euclidean, taxicab, and discrete metrics on a three-point set and list every open set. Begin with “On any finite metric space, each point has a positive minimum distance from all other points.” and finish with “Every subset is a union of singletons; Euclidean, taxicab, and discrete metrics therefore give the discrete topology here.” Then compare the result with this boundary: A nonnegative symmetric function without the triangle inequality need not support the ball-intersection proof.
The union of open balls defines a topology because arbitrary unions and finite intersections of ball-open sets remain open.
The empty set and X satisfy the ball-open condition immediately.
A point in a union inherits a ball from one member of that union.
For a finite intersection, take the smallest of the finitely many available radii.
Compare Euclidean, taxicab, and discrete metrics on a three-point set and list every open set.
- On any finite metric space, each point has a positive minimum distance from all other points.
- A ball of less than half that minimum contains only the chosen point, so every singleton is open.
- Every subset is a union of singletons; Euclidean, taxicab, and discrete metrics therefore give the discrete topology here.
Result: All eight subsets of {a,b,c} are open: ∅, the three singletons, the three two-point sets, and {a,b,c}.